Jimmie Johnson is NOT a Top Athlete
Monday 23 November, 2009 at 11:11 pm Featured, Multi-Sport 7
Jimmie Johnson has put himself in the history books with his fourth consecutive Sprint Cup series victory.
I read a disturbing article today. I read that NASCAR driver Jimmie Johnson is today’s top athlete.
Every now and then, there comes a figure who transcends his particular sport. For years it has been Tiger Woods. Now with the recent popularity increase that NASCAR has enjoyed, Jimmie Johnson – winner of four straight Sprint Cup championships – is the latest to garner consideration as America’s new top athlete.
We’ve now entered a society which is obsessed with political correctness and recognition of all activities. ESPN programming includes championship poker, billiards – they even have the Madden challenge which pits football video-gamers against one another for ultimate bragging rights. Are there endeavors considered to be ‘athletic?’
But before we walk down that road, exactly what is an athlete?
Online dictionaries define an athlete as “a person trained or gifted in exercises or contests involving physical agility, stamina, or strength; a participant in a sport, exercise, or game requiring physical skill.”
The word that stands out to me in this definition is “physical.” Physicality would imply that there is some kind of contact between competitors or contestants. Surely, race car driving requires an inordinate amount of skill. That skill encompasses the ability to control a dangerous machine as if it was one of your own limbs.
But does that skill translate Johnson into being a better athlete than Kobe, Brady or Tiger? I would think not.
Let's see Jimmie Johnson do this...without a ladder...
Jay Busbee seems to think that being head and shoulders above the competition in your genre qualifies you as being a candidate for being the top athlete across all genres. We can assume this from the following passage written by Jay:
And don’t even start the whole “the car’s the star, not the driver” nonsense. Equipment is a key element of every sport. When’s the last time you saw a baseball player succeed without a bat, or a football player succeed without pads?
This is absolutely ridiculous. But it is also what you should expect from a NASCAR blog. This is a terrible example of a biased writer defending his favorite sport. Busbee’s examples of baseball and football equipment are weak because the athletes that use them supply the power behind their effectiveness.
To the contrary, drivers aren’t required to power their equipment. While their requisite skill must enable them to maneuver their vehicles, the cars provide all the power required for success. There is also a discernible distinction in the level of physical conditioning required by the competitor. Who knows if NASCAR drivers can slam dunk a basketball? Or run a 4.5 second 40-yard dash? Or track down a fly ball at the warning track?
Jimmie Johnson is undoubtedly brilliant at what he does. But please leave it at that. Let’s not insult all of the performers that we see on the gridiron and the hardwood by claiming that Johnson is a top athlete.
He’s not even close.
T Lamont is the owner, administrator and author of all content for Ball or Nuthin\'. Feel free to contact T Lamont with a question or comment at ballornuthin@gmail.com. All created Ball or Nuthin' content is the sole property of T Lamont. Read more from this author
Loading...
This argument was stale 20 years ago when fatties like Jimmie Spencer and old men like Dave Marcis were racing every weekend, and it still makes just as little sense now.
If Tiger Woods is a top athlete, how about John Daly? If not for the mess he made of his personal life, he could have been a major force in the game. How about Olympic bobsled or luge racers? They're basically passengers, right? WRONG!!!
Basically, a racecar driver needs to have at least as much strength and physical skill as a major league baseball pitcher. Are they not athletes then either? What about hockey goalies? They mostly just need to have lightning reflexes. So does a driver. This whole argument is so subjective that it's completely pointless.
No offense, but you sound like you don't know the first thing about the subject of your article. Have you ever even driven a racecar? I used to question the "are they athletes" matter, until I actually got in and drove one of those beasts at Michigan International Speedway through Richard Petty Racing School. My questions have been answered. They're athletes. Period. Not the same kind as your beloved football and basketball heros, but athletes nonetheless.
I've played golf at the TPC "Bear" course in northern Michigan, and I've driven 170 mph on a two mile oval. I think I'll shoot par at Augusta before I make the field for the Daytona 500.
Your article makes it clear you're simply just another hater. Good luck with that.
Thanks Dan – I'm just getting back to replying to this. Much respect for your comments.
I have played baseball and as a position player, it is not physically challenging at all. Perhaps (a very long and drawn out "perhaps"), I can see your point there.
But I can tell you this – I have played basketball and football, and I can guarantee you that driving a car (no matter how aggressive or vigorous you think it is) will never physically challenge me as much as playing either of those sports.
There's a reason that basketball and football headline sports coverage. It is because even with the proper training, there's a very small amount of people who can adequately perform at that level. Much of their ability is God-given, and then honed through training.
Thanks for your comment – and I hope you can enjoy more of our non-NASCAR content!
This makes me sick, Nascar drivers are athletes just as much as Tiger woods is, heck Tiger Woods is no more of an athlete than Nascar drivers. Some people just don't understand and claim that they know everything when they don't know d*ck all. Nascar drivers as well as Formula 1, Champ Cart, Off-Road etc… They all work their a$ses off just like all other Athletes but yet they get labeled as not being Athletes? Who ever says that they are not athletes should go back to school because obviously they don't have the brains to be a sports reporter etc… Jimmie Johnson won his 4th Championship in a row but yet loads of people bash him saying that he did not deserve it, well sorry to say, Jimmie earned every Championship he got, most people who bash him are just jelious self-proclaimed nascar fans who are just mad that their favorite driver can't beat him. I know there is going to be people pi$sed at my comments but I couldnt give a rats a$$ was people think, everyone in the racing industry deserves respect, racing is not an easy sport, alot of people are all talk claiming that they can race with the best, when they cant even race a 4 cylinder race at their local short track. So who ever thinks Jimmie Johnson as well as his Pit crew who work day in and day out and every other drivers and their crew are not athletes, obviously need a brain transplant. Go watch ballet dancing or whatever you think are athletic sports and stop posting BS like this, get your facts strait and think before you post lame messages like this.
Hey FraNz 41,
My argument has nothing to do with Johnson's skill in his sport, but has to do with people labeling him as today's top athlete. I didn't say that racing is "easy." The only racing that I have ever done is on foot.
The bottom line is that he's not the best athlete…and even the big name basketball and football players may not be the best pure athletes (there's always players that have more true athleticism than the headline players).
And that is coming from an unbiased point of view.
Actually I don't think golfers or race car drivers are athelets in general. Granted some may be athletes, but neither sport requires athleticism. Personally neither does bike riding, sprinting, or running a marathon. Being athletes requires a few set of qualities. Speed, strength, quick reflexes, and coordination. If what you doesn't require all of those aspects that I'm sorry you are not an athlete. Just b/c your sport is on ESPN does not make you an athlete.
You are pretty funny dude, First of all Speed is what racing is all about, second, you have to have a lot of strength to handle driving at high rate of speed and you have to have quick reflex to avoid accidents etc.. and coordination, you need good eye coordination to even compete in racing, so don't say racing doesn't have any of those facts when in reality they do. Some people just don't know how much it takes to be a successful race car driver until they become one themselves. But like I always say, everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but the fact is race car drivers have to withstand taking big bumps and bruises from accidents in 190 – 210 mph or more. Go talk to other athletes who watch racing, and I guarantee they will say race car drivers are athletes too.
Is bloated Tony Stewart an athlete?
7 comments
This argument was stale 20 years ago when fatties like Jimmie Spencer and old men like Dave Marcis were racing every weekend, and it still makes just as little sense now.
If Tiger Woods is a top athlete, how about John Daly? If not for the mess he made of his personal life, he could have been a major force in the game. How about Olympic bobsled or luge racers? They're basically passengers, right? WRONG!!!
Basically, a racecar driver needs to have at least as much strength and physical skill as a major league baseball pitcher. Are they not athletes then either? What about hockey goalies? They mostly just need to have lightning reflexes. So does a driver. This whole argument is so subjective that it's completely pointless.
No offense, but you sound like you don't know the first thing about the subject of your article. Have you ever even driven a racecar? I used to question the "are they athletes" matter, until I actually got in and drove one of those beasts at Michigan International Speedway through Richard Petty Racing School. My questions have been answered. They're athletes. Period. Not the same kind as your beloved football and basketball heros, but athletes nonetheless.
I've played golf at the TPC "Bear" course in northern Michigan, and I've driven 170 mph on a two mile oval. I think I'll shoot par at Augusta before I make the field for the Daytona 500.
Your article makes it clear you're simply just another hater. Good luck with that.
This makes me sick, Nascar drivers are athletes just as much as Tiger woods is, heck Tiger Woods is no more of an athlete than Nascar drivers. Some people just don't understand and claim that they know everything when they don't know d*ck all. Nascar drivers as well as Formula 1, Champ Cart, Off-Road etc… They all work their a$ses off just like all other Athletes but yet they get labeled as not being Athletes? Who ever says that they are not athletes should go back to school because obviously they don't have the brains to be a sports reporter etc… Jimmie Johnson won his 4th Championship in a row but yet loads of people bash him saying that he did not deserve it, well sorry to say, Jimmie earned every Championship he got, most people who bash him are just jelious self-proclaimed nascar fans who are just mad that their favorite driver can't beat him. I know there is going to be people pi$sed at my comments but I couldnt give a rats a$$ was people think, everyone in the racing industry deserves respect, racing is not an easy sport, alot of people are all talk claiming that they can race with the best, when they cant even race a 4 cylinder race at their local short track. So who ever thinks Jimmie Johnson as well as his Pit crew who work day in and day out and every other drivers and their crew are not athletes, obviously need a brain transplant. Go watch ballet dancing or whatever you think are athletic sports and stop posting BS like this, get your facts strait and think before you post lame messages like this.
Thanks Dan – I'm just getting back to replying to this. Much respect for your comments.
I have played baseball and as a position player, it is not physically challenging at all. Perhaps (a very long and drawn out "perhaps"), I can see your point there.
But I can tell you this – I have played basketball and football, and I can guarantee you that driving a car (no matter how aggressive or vigorous you think it is) will never physically challenge me as much as playing either of those sports.
There's a reason that basketball and football headline sports coverage. It is because even with the proper training, there's a very small amount of people who can adequately perform at that level. Much of their ability is God-given, and then honed through training.
Thanks for your comment – and I hope you can enjoy more of our non-NASCAR content!
Hey FraNz 41,
My argument has nothing to do with Johnson's skill in his sport, but has to do with people labeling him as today's top athlete. I didn't say that racing is "easy." The only racing that I have ever done is on foot.
The bottom line is that he's not the best athlete…and even the big name basketball and football players may not be the best pure athletes (there's always players that have more true athleticism than the headline players).
And that is coming from an unbiased point of view.
Actually I don't think golfers or race car drivers are athelets in general. Granted some may be athletes, but neither sport requires athleticism. Personally neither does bike riding, sprinting, or running a marathon. Being athletes requires a few set of qualities. Speed, strength, quick reflexes, and coordination. If what you doesn't require all of those aspects that I'm sorry you are not an athlete. Just b/c your sport is on ESPN does not make you an athlete.
You are pretty funny dude, First of all Speed is what racing is all about, second, you have to have a lot of strength to handle driving at high rate of speed and you have to have quick reflex to avoid accidents etc.. and coordination, you need good eye coordination to even compete in racing, so don't say racing doesn't have any of those facts when in reality they do. Some people just don't know how much it takes to be a successful race car driver until they become one themselves. But like I always say, everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but the fact is race car drivers have to withstand taking big bumps and bruises from accidents in 190 – 210 mph or more. Go talk to other athletes who watch racing, and I guarantee they will say race car drivers are athletes too.
Is bloated Tony Stewart an athlete?
Leave a Reply
Your email address will not be published. Please fill the required fields...